The CLARITY Act has stalled in the Senate, leaving key questions about crypto market rules unresolved. At the same time, the Trump administration has nominated four people to fill seats at the SEC and CFTC. Two have worked on the legislation.
- The bill has not advanced in the Senate, but it has not been formally defeated.
- Trump nominated two Democrats and two Republicans across the SEC and CFTC.
- CFTC nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland have worked on the CLARITY Act.
- Confirmations could change who takes part in agency decisions, but would not expand the agencies’ legal authority.
Four nominees, two agencies, unresolved rules
The nominees are Democrat Kristin Johnson and Republican Steven Levine for the Securities and Exchange Commission, and Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
Commissioners take part in agency discussions and votes. When the nominations were announced, the SEC had two commissioners, while CFTC Chairman Michael Selig was the CFTC’s only serving commissioner. If confirmed, the four nominees would add members to the agencies’ decision-making bodies.
The SEC and CFTC oversee different parts of U.S. financial markets. The SEC regulates securities markets, while the CFTC oversees commodity derivatives markets, including futures and swaps. Which agency’s rules apply to a particular crypto asset or trading activity, or whether both agencies’ rules apply, depends on the facts and the relevant law.
The CLARITY Act aims to establish a framework for crypto market structure, including how responsibility for digital assets is divided. The bill has not advanced in the Senate. Here, “stalled” means no Senate progress has been reported. It does not mean lawmakers have formally rejected the bill.
A legislative impasse does not give regulators new powers. The SEC and CFTC remain bound by the authority Congress has granted them. But when Congress leaves disputed questions unresolved, how agencies interpret and apply existing laws still matters, and their decisions can be challenged in court.
Two CFTC nominees have worked on the bill
Anonick is legislative counsel to Senate Agriculture Committee Chairman John Boozman. He was a lead negotiator on the committee’s work on the CLARITY Act. The available details do not identify a separate bill or draft as the focus of that work.
Rowland is a CFTC attorney who has also worked on the CLARITY Act. Earlier in his career, he worked with Democratic senators Amy Klobuchar and Debbie Stabenow on the Senate Agriculture Committee.
Their experience could bring familiarity with the bill’s negotiations to the CFTC. It does not, on its own, show which provisions either nominee would support as a commissioner. The Senate Agriculture Committee is handling their nominations, but no hearing date for them appears in the available schedule.
Different backgrounds at the SEC
Johnson served as a CFTC commissioner from 2022 to 2025. Her areas of focus included digital-asset regulation, customer protection, risk management, and market integrity. Her past work gives her direct experience with the CFTC and digital-asset policy, but it does not establish how she would vote on specific SEC matters.
Levine previously served as counsel and deputy chief of staff to former SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda. He later worked as general counsel and senior adviser at the White House Council of Economic Advisers. He would fill the SEC seat previously held by Hester Peirce, who led the agency’s Crypto Task Force and advocated for clearer crypto rules.
The nominees’ backgrounds offer context, but they do not fully explain the policies either would pursue. The nominations alone do not settle questions about crypto custody, DeFi oversight, or how the agencies should divide responsibility.
What happens next?
The Senate must consider the nominations, and confirmation is not automatic. The Senate Banking Committee is responsible for Johnson and Levine, while the Agriculture Committee is handling Anonick and Rowland. A hearing for Johnson and Levine was scheduled for November 19, but the year was not specified in the available scheduling details. Their current status cannot be established here.
Changes in Senate control can affect the chamber’s agenda and the chances of confirming nominees, but the dates provided do not set a firm confirmation deadline. Filling the seats would not replace legislation. Commissioners can make decisions under existing law, while Congress can set a broader framework if lawmakers reach an agreement. The debate over how that framework should divide responsibilities has been narrowing to SEC versus CFTC rules.
Key questions and answers
-
What does it mean that the CLARITY Act has stalled?
The bill has not advanced in the Senate. That describes its reported progress, not a formal defeat or rejection.
-
Who are the SEC and CFTC nominees?
Kristin Johnson and Steven Levine are nominated for the SEC. Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland are nominated for the CFTC.
-
Which nominees have worked on the CLARITY Act?
Anonick was a lead negotiator on the Agriculture Committee’s work on the bill, and Rowland has also worked on it.
-
Why do the nominations matter for crypto?
If confirmed, the nominees could take part in agency decisions while Congress has yet to advance a market-structure framework. Their appointments would not expand the SEC’s or CFTC’s statutory authority.
-
Have the four nominees been confirmed?
The available information does not establish any confirmation outcomes. The Agriculture Committee had not announced a hearing date for its two nominees.