As of November 12, 2025, Washington’s crypto-policy fights were unfolding on three fronts: a federal-state dispute over sports prediction markets, questions about safeguards for tokenized shares, and nominations to fill vacancies at the SEC and CFTC.
- Trump nominated two candidates each to the CFTC and SEC.
- Four Democratic senators asked how the SEC would protect investors in tokenized-equity markets.
- The CFTC’s sports-contract disputes involved 12 states, as federal and state officials fought over who has authority.
CFTC and states contest authority over sports markets
The CFTC’s lawsuits against Arkansas and Louisiana brought to 12 the number of states involved in court disputes over sports-related prediction markets. The cases turn on a basic question with real consequences for operators and customers: are contracts tied to sports outcomes federally regulated derivatives, or gambling products governed by state law?
The CFTC and prediction-market operators say the contracts are swaps subject to federal oversight. State officials say they amount to sports wagering, which states regulate. No ruling described here has settled the dispute. Prediction markets and event contracts sit at the heart of this regulatory divide.
Geofencing, which restricts access to a market based on a user’s location, has become a flashpoint. In a November 5, 2025, communication to designated contract markets (DCMs), the CFTC said they should disregard certain state and tribal injunctions requiring geofencing. The agency argued that excluding specific jurisdictions conflicts with the Commodity Exchange Act’s “impartial access requirements.”
Nine Democratic senators urged the CFTC to reverse its position, saying it “directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed.” The dispute goes beyond how a platform sets up its service. It also raises the question of whether federal regulators can displace state enforcement while courts consider who has jurisdiction.
CFTC Chair Michael Selig sharply criticized Louisiana’s lawsuit, calling it “naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt.” He also said it was “really egregious” for states to bring criminal charges against founders and executives offering products he considers lawful under a federal regime.
Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill accused Selig of making “flatly false statements” and called him the “obsequious standard bearer” for Kalshi and prediction markets. The rhetoric is fierce, but neither an agency chair’s view nor a state official’s accusation settles the legal question.
Republican Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas has also criticized sports prediction markets, calling them “a thinly veiled way to get around state laws regulating gambling.” He argued gambling should be left to the states “rather than a federal back door that circumvents state regulation.” His position shows that this is not simply a partisan dispute. It is a broader fight over where federal derivatives oversight ends and state gambling authority begins.
Trump nominates four agency commissioners
On November 12, 2025, the White House confirmed that President Donald Trump had sent four commissioner nominations to the Senate. They were his first Democratic nominees to either agency since returning to the White House.
For the CFTC, Trump nominated Nathan Anonick, a Republican and legal counsel to Sen. John Boozman (R-Ark.), for a term expiring in June 2031. Matthew Rowland, a Democrat and career CFTC attorney who served in the agency’s enforcement division, was nominated for a term expiring in April 2028.
The SEC nominees are Kristin Johnson, a Democrat and former CFTC commissioner whose term ended in September 2025, for a term expiring in June 2029, and Steven Levine, a Republican and former deputy chief of staff to SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda, for a term expiring in June 2030.
Anonick and Rowland both helped their parties negotiate the CLARITY Act, digital-asset market-structure legislation that failed in the Senate in September. Their experience ties the nominations to the unresolved effort to define how federal agencies oversee crypto markets.
Both commissions had multiple vacancies when the nominations were announced. The SEC had three of its five seats vacant, while the CFTC had four vacancies. CFTC Chair Michael Selig had been the agency’s only commissioner for 11 months. The Senate Agriculture Committee scheduled a confirmation hearing for the CFTC nominees on November 17, 2025, and the Senate Banking Committee scheduled one for the SEC nominees on November 19.
“Two strong bipartisan picks, ” Selig said of the CFTC nominees.
SEC Chair Paul Atkins had not commented on the nominations as of November 12. Filling the seats could give the agencies more capacity and a wider range of views. But confirmation alone will not settle disputes over jurisdiction, market access or investor protection.
Senators ask how tokenized shares will be protected
Four Democratic senators, Angela Alsobrooks, Catherine Cortez Masto, Ruben Gallego and Mark Warner, wrote to Atkins, saying the SEC’s tokenization effort “lacks clarity.” Their letter asked more than a dozen questions about how securities rules and investor safeguards would apply when shares are represented or traded using digital tokens.
Tokenized shares use digital tokens to represent assets such as company shares. But holding a token does not automatically mean you own the underlying share or have the same legal rights. Those rights depend on how the product is structured and what legal claim the token represents.
The senators focused on know-your-customer (KYC) and anti-money-laundering (AML) requirements, which help verify customers and deter financial crime. They asked how those safeguards would work with trading that could run 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and transfers to self-custodied wallets, which users control rather than a third-party custodian.
Self-custody does not make compliance impossible. The practical answer may depend on the token’s design, the trading system and whether transfers are permissioned or subject to controls. The senators want the SEC to explain how those safeguards will work, rather than leave investors and firms guessing. Tokenized securities markets require strong investor protections, not a vague promise that technology will sort everything out.
They warned that the effort “could undermine the integrity of our capital markets and threaten public companies and investors alike” if protections are unclear.
“Tokenization must uphold the safeguards that make the U.S.’s capital markets the envy of the world, ” the senators wrote.
Some descriptions of the SEC’s tokenization plans use labels such as “innovation exemption” and “Reg Crypto.” Those labels do not mean there is a blanket exemption from securities law. The senators’ questions concern which requirements would apply to specific activities and how investor protections would work in practice.
Key questions and answers
-
Who did Trump nominate to the CFTC and SEC?
Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland were nominated to the CFTC; Kristin Johnson and Steven Levine were nominated to the SEC. The Senate confirmation process was still pending as of November 12, 2025.
-
Why are senators questioning the SEC’s tokenization plans?
They want clarity on investor protections and KYC and AML safeguards, especially for round-the-clock trading and transfers to self-custodied wallets. A token’s legal rights and transfer controls depend on how the product is structured.
-
Why is the CFTC in court over sports prediction markets?
The CFTC and operators argue that sports event contracts are federally regulated swaps. States argue they are gambling products under state law. Courts have yet to settle the jurisdictional dispute described here. The overlap of CFTC pressure and state rules reflects a wider fight over who sets the boundaries.
-
How many states were involved in the CFTC’s court disputes?
Twelve, after the CFTC brought cases involving Arkansas and Louisiana. A separate dispute concerns the agency’s November 5 communication about state and tribal injunctions requiring DCMs to geofence customers.
Tokenized equities and sports prediction markets are both testing old regulatory boundaries. The technology may change how assets move or contracts are traded, but it does not determine who has authority or which protections apply. Until regulators, lawmakers and courts set clearer boundaries, firms will face competing claims. Customers will need to look past the labels and check what rights and safeguards they actually have.